Editing Talk:Dominion League

Hi Wiki people! I hope I'm not overstepping my bounds, but since the success of the Dominion League, I thought it might be neat to keep some records of the players and scores in the top group (which I guess we should call Division A). I think the records should just be limited to games in the top division. Feel free to make changes, give feedback, discuss, or let me know if this doesn't belong on the wiki. --Arcticpenguin
: I think this totally belongs on the wiki (which isn't that weird, as I've been adding the old tournaments). I think it might be a good idea to separate the seasons though. I'd like to help to fill in the complete standings for each season (after I've finished the other tournaments). Maybe a list of the champions of the league (winner A or winner Championshipmatch) would be nice. [[User:Hugovj|Hugovj]] ([[User talk:Hugovj|talk]]) 10:25, 24 April 2015 (EDT)
: Great, I'm glad you like it! I was going to respond to your forum message as that's what made me want to start an article about the League. I like having all the Division A stats on one page, but I agree that this page could serve as a nice index that sends you off to pages for each season, assuming someone wants to write a bit about the season. For that reason, I think it would be nice to keep the tables with the Division A final standings here for easy access to records, but also include them in each season's own page (and if someone really wants to delve into all of the lower division participants and standings they should probably be on the separate Season page only). Under the standings table we could say a little bit about the season and link to the season specific page for more information. We could also include the final Kingdoms, especially now that some of them are designed and not random, and maybe even game descriptions for the Championship match and links to commentary. It might even be nice to highlight some of the most interesting games of the Division A regular season as well, with descriptions and links to commentary/videos. --[[User:Arcticpenguin|Arcticpenguin]] ([[User talk:Arcticpenguin|talk]]) 13:33, 24 April 2015 (EDT)
@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 Hi Wiki people! I hope I'm not overstepping my bounds, but since the success of the Dominion League, I thought it might be neat to keep some records of the players and scores in the top group (which I guess we should call Division A). I think the records should just be limited to games in the top division. Feel free to make changes, give feedback, discuss, or let me know if this doesn't belong on the wiki. --Arcticpenguin
 : I think this totally belongs on the wiki (which isn't that weird, as I've been adding the old tournaments). I think it might be a good idea to separate the seasons though. I'd like to help to fill in the complete standings for each season (after I've finished the other tournaments). Maybe a list of the champions of the league (winner A or winner Championshipmatch) would be nice. [[User:Hugovj|Hugovj]] ([[User talk:Hugovj|talk]]) 10:25, 24 April 2015 (EDT)
-:: Great, I'm glad you like it! I was going to respond to your forum message as that's what made me want to start an article about the League. I like having all the Division A stats on one page, but I agree that this page could serve as a nice index that sends you off to pages for each season, assuming someone wants to write a bit about the season. For that reason, I think it would be nice to keep the tables with the Division A final standings here for easy access to records, but also include them in each season's own page (and if someone really wants to delve into all of the lower division participants and standings they should probably be on the separate Season page only). Under the standings table we could say a little bit about the season and link to the season specific page for more information. We could also include the final Kingdoms, especially now that some of them are designed and not random, and maybe even game descriptions for the Championship match and links to commentary. It might even be nice to highlight some of the most interesting games of the Division A regular season as well, with descriptions and links to commentary/videos. --[[User:Arcticpenguin|Arcticpenguin]] ([[User talk:Arcticpenguin|talk]]) 13:33, 24 April 2015 (EDT)
+: Great, I'm glad you like it! I was going to respond to your forum message as that's what made me want to start an article about the League. I like having all the Division A stats on one page, but I agree that this page could serve as a nice index that sends you off to pages for each season, assuming someone wants to write a bit about the season. For that reason, I think it would be nice to keep the tables with the Division A final standings here for easy access to records, but also include them in each season's own page (and if someone really wants to delve into all of the lower division participants and standings they should probably be on the separate Season page only). Under the standings table we could say a little bit about the season and link to the season specific page for more information. We could also include the final Kingdoms, especially now that some of them are designed and not random, and maybe even game descriptions for the Championship match and links to commentary. It might even be nice to highlight some of the most interesting games of the Division A regular season as well, with descriptions and links to commentary/videos. --[[User:Arcticpenguin|Arcticpenguin]] ([[User talk:Arcticpenguin|talk]]) 13:33, 24 April 2015 (EDT)
-::: Well, that seems like a lot of work ^^ However, I like all the points you proposed here. I don't know about the A-league results being shown on the front page, but if you think that's better, I'm okay with it as is. I don't know if, let's say season 15 comes here, the page will still be easy to read. I really like the idea to include the final kingdoms, I hadn't thought about that. Also, if you still have comments on the other points in the post on the forums, please do respond there :) [[User:Hugovj|Hugovj]] ([[User talk:Hugovj|talk]]) 14:24, 24 April 2015 (EDT)
-It would be also good to have the score of the Championship match !
-: I originally included championship match games in the tallies but feedback from Stef and Mic Qsenoch made it clear that it wasn't a good idea. Once one player wins enough games to guarantee the championship, which usually happens well before all 6 games are played, the rest of the match is not taken too seriously. Often one of the players leaves and is replaced by someone else, and before the kingdoms were designed sometimes the match just ended after 4 games. I suppose we could say X won the match with a score of 3 to 1 (i.e. just stopping the count after the game that decided the match rather than after all 6 games) and still not including any of those games in the tallies. I think it might also be good to include the designed Kingdoms from the Championship match, and maybe even some match reports from the most memorable games and kingdoms. --[[User:Arcticpenguin|Arcticpenguin]] ([[User talk:Arcticpenguin|talk]]) 11:57, 24 June 2015 (EDT)