Editing Duration
Warning: You are not logged in.
Your IP address will be recorded in this page's edit history.The edit can be undone.
Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
| Latest revision | Your text | ||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
'''Duration''' is a [[card type]] that was introduced in [[Seaside]] and revisited in later sets, starting with [[Adventures]]. Duration cards have orange frames, and usually have an effect on the turn after they are played. A Duration is not discarded from play until the Cleanup phase of the last turn on which it does something - usually the turn after the turn on which it is played. | '''Duration''' is a [[card type]] that was introduced in [[Seaside]] and revisited in later sets, starting with [[Adventures]]. Duration cards have orange frames, and usually have an effect on the turn after they are played. A Duration is not discarded from play until the Cleanup phase of the last turn on which it does something - usually the turn after the turn on which it is played. | ||
| − | The majority of Duration cards are [[Action]] cards, but a few belong to the [[Night]] type introduced in [[Nocturne | + | The majority of Duration cards are [[Action]] cards, but a few belong to the [[Night]] type introduced in [[Nocturne]]. |
== List of Duration cards == | == List of Duration cards == | ||
| − | * {{Cost|2}} | + | * {{Cost|2}} {{Card|Guardian}}, {{Card|Haven}}, {{Card|Lighthouse}} |
| − | * {{Cost|3}} {{Card|Amulet | + | * {{Cost|3}} {{Card|Amulet}}, {{Card|Caravan Guard}}, {{Card|Cargo Ship}}, {{Card|Church}}, {{Card|Dungeon}}, {{Card|Enchantress}}, {{Card|Fishing Village}}, {{Card|Gear}}, {{Card|Ghost Town}}, {{card|Importer}}, {{Card|Secret Cave}} |
| − | * {{Cost|4}} | + | * {{Cost|4}} {{Card|Caravan}}, {{card|Conjurer}}, {{Card|Research}}, {{card|Royal Galley}}, {{Card|Village Green}}, {{card|Garrison}}, {{card|Voyage}} |
* {{cost|4*}} {{Card|Ghost}} | * {{cost|4*}} {{Card|Ghost}} | ||
| − | * {{Cost|5}} {{Card|Archive}}, {{Card|Barge}}, {{Card|Bridge Troll | + | * {{Cost|5}} {{Card|Archive}}, {{Card|Barge}}, {{Card|Bridge Troll}}, {{Card|Cobbler}}, {{card|Contract}}, {{Card|Crypt}}, {{Card|Den of Sin}}, {{card|Gatekeeper}}, {{Card|Haunted Woods}}, {{card|Highwayman}}, {{Card|Mastermind}}, {{Card|Merchant Ship}}, {{Card|Outpost}}, {{Card|Swamp Hag}}, {{Card|Tactician}}, {{card|Warlord}}, {{Card|Wharf}} |
* {{Cost|6}} {{Card|Captain}}, {{Card|Hireling}}, {{Card|Raider}}, {{card|Stronghold}} | * {{Cost|6}} {{Card|Captain}}, {{Card|Hireling}}, {{Card|Raider}}, {{card|Stronghold}} | ||
* {{Cost|6*}} {{Card|Champion}} | * {{Cost|6*}} {{Card|Champion}} | ||
| − | * {{cost| | + | * {{cost|8}} <span class="card-popup">[[Prince]]<span class="noprint">[[File:PrinceDigital.jpg|200px|link=]]</span></span> |
| − | + | ||
== Official Rules == | == Official Rules == | ||
| − | + | * Duration cards are orange, and have abilities that affect future turns. | |
| − | * Duration cards are not discarded in Clean-up if they have something left to do | + | * Duration cards are not discarded in Clean-up if they have something left to do; they stay in play until the Clean-up of the last turn that they do something. |
| − | * Additionally, if a Duration card is played extra times by a card such as [{{Card|Throne Room}}, {{Card|Scepter}}, {{Card|Mastermind}} | + | * Additionally, if a Duration card is played extra times by a card such as [{{Card|Throne Room}}, {{Card|Scepter}}, {{Card|Mastermind}} or {{Card|Specialist}}], that card also stays in play until the Duration card is discarded, to track the fact that the Duration card was played extra times. |
| − | * Keep track of whether or not a Duration card was played on the current turn, such as by putting your cards into two lines | + | * Keep track of whether or not a Duration card was played on the current turn, such as by putting your cards into two lines. |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
== Other rules clarifications == | == Other rules clarifications == | ||
In most cases, a Duration will stay in play until the Clean-up phase of your next turn. But a Duration card played in such a way as to have no effect next turn will be discarded from play the turn it was played. This may happen because the next-turn effects are optional and you chose not to activate them (e.g. {{card|Barge}}), or because they are conditional and that condition wasn't met (e.g., a {{card|Tactician}} that didn't discard any cards), or if you didn't follow the card's instructions at all (due to {{Card|Enchantress}} or [[Way]]s). A card like {{Card|Caravan}} that provides +Cards on your next turn stays in play even if you won't have enough cards in your deck to draw any next turn. A Duration played this turn that won't stay in play can be trashed with {{Card|Improve}}. | In most cases, a Duration will stay in play until the Clean-up phase of your next turn. But a Duration card played in such a way as to have no effect next turn will be discarded from play the turn it was played. This may happen because the next-turn effects are optional and you chose not to activate them (e.g. {{card|Barge}}), or because they are conditional and that condition wasn't met (e.g., a {{card|Tactician}} that didn't discard any cards), or if you didn't follow the card's instructions at all (due to {{Card|Enchantress}} or [[Way]]s). A card like {{Card|Caravan}} that provides +Cards on your next turn stays in play even if you won't have enough cards in your deck to draw any next turn. A Duration played this turn that won't stay in play can be trashed with {{Card|Improve}}. | ||
| − | Some Durations can stay out for longer than one turn. Durations that set cards aside and return them to you one at a time ( | + | Some Durations can stay out for longer than one turn. Durations that set cards aside and return them to you one at a time (like {{Card|Archive}} and {{Card|Crypt}}) remain in play until they run out of cards. {{Card|Voyage}} stays in play until the Clean-up of its extra turn; if you take multiple extra turns at once, {{Card|Voyage}} could stay out for more than one turn. {{Card|Champion}}, {{Card|Hireling}}, and <span class="card-popup">[[Prince]]<span class="noprint">[[File:PrinceDigital.jpg|200px|link=]]</span></span> stay in play permanently. |
| − | + | When you use a [[Throne Room variant]] on a Duration, it stays in play for as long as the Duration does. This is the case even if the Duration is only going to have one effect on the next turn (e.g., if you play a {{card|Tactician}} twice with {{Card|Throne Room}}, or if you play a {{card|Barge}} twice with {{Card|Throne Room}} and opt for one same-turn effect and one next-turn effect). If the Duration leaves play at an unusual time (such as a {{Card|Highwayman}} that's discarded at the start of your turn), the {{Card|Throne Room}} still stays in play until Clean-up. If a card that plays other cards only once, such as {{Card|Elder}} or {{Card|Herald}}, causes a Duration to be played, the Elder/Herald/etc. does not stay in play; only Throne Room variants, which cause the same Duration to be played multiple times, remain in play with Durations. | |
| − | + | ||
| − | When you use a [[Throne Room variant]] on a Duration, | + | |
Effects that resolve at the start of your turn can be resolved in any order; this includes multiple plays of the same Duration card by a Throne Room variant. For example, if you both played a {{Card|Wharf}} and played a {{Card|Throne Room}} on an {{Card|Amulet}} last turn, on this turn you could choose to first gain a {{Card|Silver}} from the first {{Card|Amulet}} play, then draw 2 cards from {{Card|Wharf}} (perhaps triggering a [[reshuffle]] and maybe drawing that {{Card|Silver}}), and then choose to trash a card with the second {{Card|Amulet}} play. | Effects that resolve at the start of your turn can be resolved in any order; this includes multiple plays of the same Duration card by a Throne Room variant. For example, if you both played a {{Card|Wharf}} and played a {{Card|Throne Room}} on an {{Card|Amulet}} last turn, on this turn you could choose to first gain a {{Card|Silver}} from the first {{Card|Amulet}} play, then draw 2 cards from {{Card|Wharf}} (perhaps triggering a [[reshuffle]] and maybe drawing that {{Card|Silver}}), and then choose to trash a card with the second {{Card|Amulet}} play. | ||
| − | + | If you use a [[Command variant]] to play a Duration card without putting it into play (e.g., {{card|Band of Misfits}}, an {{card|Estate}} after using {{event|Inheritance}} on a Duration card, or any Action card using {{way|Way of the Mouse}} to play a Duration), the Command variant stays in play as long as the Duration card would. If the same Command variant plays multiple Duration cards that would stay in play for different amounts of time (e.g. using {{Card|Throne Room}} on {{Card|Overlord}}, and it plays a {{Card|Swamp Hag}} and an {{Card|Archive}}), it stays in play until the last of those Duration cards would leave play (in this example, probably the {{Card|Archive}}). These rules also apply if a Command variant plays a Throne Room variant that would stay in play for multiple turns because ''it'' played a Duration card, or another Command variant that would stay in play for multiple turns, etc.: Command variants stay in play for as long as the card they command ''would'' stay in play, if it were in play. (However, <span class="card-popup">[[Prince]]<span class="noprint">[[File:PrinceDigital.jpg|200px|link=]]</span></span> and {{card|Captain}} are Command variants that are ''themselves'' Duration cards, and so they may stay in play for longer!) | |
| − | If | + | If you play a {{card|Throne Room}} that plays a ''non''-Duration card that stays in play (such as another {{Card|Throne Room}} that plays a Duration twice, or a {{Card|Band of Misfits}} that plays a Duration), the first {{Card|Throne Room}} does not stay out. However, if you {{Card|Mastermind}} a {{Card|Mastermind}}, it's possible to have a chain of {{Card|Mastermind}}s stuck in play for several turns if they keep playing Duration cards, because {{Card|Mastermind}} is itself a Duration. |
| − | + | It is occasionally possible to remove Duration cards from play before they are done resolving all their abilities. Examples include trashing a Duration with {{Event|Bonfire}} (early version), using {{Card|Counterfeit}} (early version) on {{Card|Contract}}, or using {{Card|Throne Room}} on a Duration, and playing it once for its normal effect, and once as {{Way|Way of the Turtle}}. In most cases, the Duration card's effects will still carry over to future turns, which you will have to remember. Exceptions include Durations that won't have any effect if they're not in play, such as {{Card|Garrison}} (which can't have tokens if not in play) and {{Card|Conjurer}} (which can't return itself to your hand). If any [[Throne Room variant]] or [[Command variant]] was supposed to stay in play because of the the now-removed Duration card, it will be discarded from play during Clean-up. | |
| − | It | + | It's also possible for a Duration card to remain in play during your Clean-up, and yet discard itself from play during Clean-up of another player's turn. This may happen if you play a {{Card|Voyage}}, and then have its extra turn gets skipped with {{Card|Lich}}. (Skipping a turn with {{Card|Lich}} happens between turns and not during Clean-up, which is why {{Card|Voyage}} still stays in play during your turn.) Since you don't get a Clean-up phase during a skipped turn, the {{Card|Voyage}} will stay in play until the Clean-up of the next turn that happens (either yours or another player's). |
| − | + | {{Card|Possession}} is not a Duration card, even though it does have effects on future turns, and so the Duration rules do not apply to it. (The same was true of an <span class="card-popup">[[Prince|earlier version of Prince]]<span class="noprint">[[File:PrinceOld2.jpg|200px|link=]]</span></span>, but after the card was revised in 2022, <span class="card-popup">[[Prince]]<span class="noprint">[[File:PrinceDigital.jpg|200px|link=]]</span></span> now is a Duration.) For example, unlike {{Card|Outpost}}, {{Card|Possession}} is discarded before the extra turn it creates. And if you play it twice with {{Card|Throne Room}}, the {{Card|Throne Room}} doesn't stay in play. | |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
| − | + | ||
== Prior Rules == | == Prior Rules == | ||
| Line 56: | Line 45: | ||
* Originally, cards that played cards that played Durations extra times were left in play as well (e.g. Throne Room plays Throne Room that plays a Duration). This was changed via a ruling to only be the card that directly played the Duration extra times was left out. | * Originally, cards that played cards that played Durations extra times were left in play as well (e.g. Throne Room plays Throne Room that plays a Duration). This was changed via a ruling to only be the card that directly played the Duration extra times was left out. | ||
* Also, originally the cards playing Durations extra times stayed in play only until ''they'' stopped doing something. This was changed with the release of [[Empires]] to have them always stay in play until the ''Duration'' left play instead. This affects situations where either the Duration leaves play earlier (e.g. {{Card|Procession}}) or the extra play(s) of the card didn't trigger the Duration effect (e.g. when playing {{Card|Tactician}} with a Throne Room under normal circumstances). | * Also, originally the cards playing Durations extra times stayed in play only until ''they'' stopped doing something. This was changed with the release of [[Empires]] to have them always stay in play until the ''Duration'' left play instead. This affects situations where either the Duration leaves play earlier (e.g. {{Card|Procession}}) or the extra play(s) of the card didn't trigger the Duration effect (e.g. when playing {{Card|Tactician}} with a Throne Room under normal circumstances). | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
== Strategy == | == Strategy == | ||
| − | On the turn on which they are played, Duration cards typically have weak effects (relative to their cost), or even detrimental effects; their strength comes in part from the fact that their effects on the next turn do not consume an Action to play or a card slot in your hand. For example, {{Card|Caravan}}, on the turn it is played, is a [[cantrip]] with no effect; on the next turn, however, it gives you a sixth card in your hand for free—thus playing a Caravan on one turn has the same effect as playing a {{Card|Laboratory}} | + | On the turn on which they are played, Duration cards typically have weak effects (relative to their cost), or even detrimental effects; their strength comes in part from the fact that their effects on the next turn do not consume an Action to play or a card slot in your hand. For example, {{Card|Caravan}}, on the turn it is played, is a [[cantrip]] with no effect; on the next turn, however, it gives you a sixth card in your hand for free—thus playing a Caravan on one turn has the same effect as playing a {{Card|Laboratory}} on the next turn. |
Although Duration cards' next-turn effects are typically quite strong, they cost less than and are usually considered weaker than cards that have those same effects immediately—for instance, Caravan costs {{Cost|4}} while Laboratory costs {{Cost|5}}. This is in part because it's better to receive benefits earlier—playing a Caravan on the last turn of the game gives no benefit while Laboratory does—and in part because the fact that Durations stay in play for two turns is a disadvantage, since it means that they can actually be played less frequently. For instance, it's possible to draw an extra card every turn by having a single Laboratory and playing it every turn; in order to play a Caravan every turn, you have to have two copies of the card. | Although Duration cards' next-turn effects are typically quite strong, they cost less than and are usually considered weaker than cards that have those same effects immediately—for instance, Caravan costs {{Cost|4}} while Laboratory costs {{Cost|5}}. This is in part because it's better to receive benefits earlier—playing a Caravan on the last turn of the game gives no benefit while Laboratory does—and in part because the fact that Durations stay in play for two turns is a disadvantage, since it means that they can actually be played less frequently. For instance, it's possible to draw an extra card every turn by having a single Laboratory and playing it every turn; in order to play a Caravan every turn, you have to have two copies of the card. | ||
[[Reserve]] cards can play rather similarly to Durations; most have a weak effect now for a stronger effect later. The difference is that Reserves don't have to be triggered on your next turn; you can wait a few turns to use them, or even use some of them the same turn you play them. | [[Reserve]] cards can play rather similarly to Durations; most have a weak effect now for a stronger effect later. The difference is that Reserves don't have to be triggered on your next turn; you can wait a few turns to use them, or even use some of them the same turn you play them. | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
== Trivia == | == Trivia == | ||
| Line 83: | Line 66: | ||
==== Development ==== | ==== Development ==== | ||
{{Quote | {{Quote | ||
| − | |Text= | + | |Text=For Seaside I was still interacting with Valerie and Dale. Valerie in particular did not like Duration cards. So the push was to limit how many there were, not come up with more things for them to do. In fact Haven was out of the set for a while, and made it back in very late when it turned out there was room for a 26th card (and that was a fine card that had been tested; Valerie had felt it was too similar to Caravan). |
| − | < | + | <br> |
| − | There was an attack that hit other players' turns (Tax Collector, made cards cost {{Cost|1}} more), that left (well turned into {{Card|Cutpurse}}) because it would have left play at a different time from other Duration cards, (end of the prev. player's turn) and Valerie didn't like that. Late in the going I realized I could save | + | There was an attack that hit other players' turns (Tax Collector, made cards cost {{Cost|1}} more), that left (well turned into {{Card|Cutpurse}}) because it would have left play at a different time from other Duration cards, (end of the prev. player's turn) and Valerie didn't like that. Late in the going I realized I could save Lighthouse by having it produce resources on your next turn, and of course that same solution could have been used for attacks; but Tax Collector had already turned into Cutpurse and again there was anti-demand for new Duration cards. |
|Name=[[Donald X. Vaccarino]] | |Name=[[Donald X. Vaccarino]] | ||
|Source=[http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=11958.msg477977#msg477977 Groundless speculation about the 2015 expansion] | |Source=[http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=11958.msg477977#msg477977 Groundless speculation about the 2015 expansion] | ||
| Line 93: | Line 76: | ||
|Text=It goes back to before the cards had "duration" on the bottom of them. Something has to track what you're getting next turn. The duration card stays out because it has "something left to do"; the idea is, the Throne also has something left to do. | |Text=It goes back to before the cards had "duration" on the bottom of them. Something has to track what you're getting next turn. The duration card stays out because it has "something left to do"; the idea is, the Throne also has something left to do. | ||
| − | In retrospect it would have been better if duration cards not in play didn't do anything (and, if cards you couldn't put into play also didn't do anything). That clears up {{Card|Procession | + | In retrospect it would have been better if duration cards not in play didn't do anything (and, if cards you couldn't put into play also didn't do anything). That clears up {{Card|Procession}}. |
{{Card|Outpost}} has an anti-Throne clause. Ideally it would have some form that didn't need that. | {{Card|Outpost}} has an anti-Throne clause. Ideally it would have some form that didn't need that. | ||
| Line 104: | Line 87: | ||
==== Ways and removing Durations from play ==== | ==== Ways and removing Durations from play ==== | ||
{{Quote | {{Quote | ||
| − | |Text=[{{Way|Way of the Butterfly}}, {{Way|Way of the Horse}}, and {{ | + | |Text=[{{Way|Way of the Butterfly}}, {{Way|Way of the Horse}}, and {{Card|Way of the Turtle}}] all existed in January for me. The best solution is still to make the change that means {{Card|Throne Room|Throne}}/{{Card|Feast}} no longer works and people quit the game. "If this isn't a Duration card" was too awful for the Ways. They could have had a general rule that durations didn't get to use Ways; maybe that's still worth considering for a later printing, but they didn't get it. There had to be new cards and those new cards got to exist. |
|Name=[[Donald X. Vaccarino]] | |Name=[[Donald X. Vaccarino]] | ||
|Source=[http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=5799.msg847400#msg847400 Interview with Donald X.] | |Source=[http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=5799.msg847400#msg847400 Interview with Donald X.] | ||
}} | }} | ||
| − | ==== | + | ==== Lack of Treasure-Durations ==== |
{{Quote | {{Quote | ||
| − | |Text=By default they're trouble. The duration part has to be conditional on the card being in play, to avoid more problems ala | + | |Text=By default they're trouble. The duration part has to be conditional on the card being in play, to avoid more problems ala {{Event|Bonfire}} / Durations. It's doable, in the same way that {{Card|Crown}} exists despite it seeming like there would never be an Action - Treasure (to be fair {{Card|Crown}} does generate lots of questions). But, it would take something really compelling. |
|Name=[[Donald X. Vaccarino]] | |Name=[[Donald X. Vaccarino]] | ||
| − | |Source=[http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=5799.msg826707#msg826707 Interview with Donald X. | + | |Source=[http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=5799.msg826707#msg826707 Interview with Donald X.] |
}} | }} | ||
==== Durations in later expansions ==== | ==== Durations in later expansions ==== | ||
| − | Every expansion | + | Every expansion after {{Set|Adventures}} has had at least two Duration cards. |
{{Quote | {{Quote | ||
|Text= | |Text= | ||
Originally all sets from {{Set|Seaside}} on were going to have Duration cards; {{Card|Fishing Village}} for example was from {{Set|Prosperity}}. This didn't happen because of how things went down for Valerie with {{Set|Seaside}}; she didn't like Duration cards, and spent a couple pages on the rules for them. My rulebook only spends a short paragraph on Durations, and I like them, and they are very popular with players. They open up card possibilities significantly, especially for Attacks. So, I'm happy having a couple nice ones in an expansion like that, and always have been. And it's no trouble, it's easy to make them. | Originally all sets from {{Set|Seaside}} on were going to have Duration cards; {{Card|Fishing Village}} for example was from {{Set|Prosperity}}. This didn't happen because of how things went down for Valerie with {{Set|Seaside}}; she didn't like Duration cards, and spent a couple pages on the rules for them. My rulebook only spends a short paragraph on Durations, and I like them, and they are very popular with players. They open up card possibilities significantly, especially for Attacks. So, I'm happy having a couple nice ones in an expansion like that, and always have been. And it's no trouble, it's easy to make them. | ||
|Name=[[Donald X. Vaccarino]] | |Name=[[Donald X. Vaccarino]] | ||
| − | |Source=[http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=5799.msg874639#msg874639 Interview with Donald X. | + | |Source=[http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index.php?topic=5799.msg874639#msg874639 Interview with Donald X.] |
}} | }} | ||
{{Navbox Seaside}} | {{Navbox Seaside}} | ||
{{Navbox Adventures}} | {{Navbox Adventures}} | ||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
{{Navbox card types}} | {{Navbox card types}} | ||
[[Category:Multi-expansion special card types]] | [[Category:Multi-expansion special card types]] | ||
