Editing Lose Track rule

Jump to: navigation, search

Warning: You are not logged in.

Your IP address will be recorded in this page's edit history.
The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then save the changes below to finish undoing the edit.
Latest revision Your text
Line 1: Line 1:
[[Image:LoseTrackEx1.jpg|thumb|right|361px|[[Procession]] playing a [[Madman]] loses track of that card once Madman has moved itself away [[in play|from play]], to return to its pile.]]
+
The '''Lose Track rule''' is a rule covering what to do with a card when it is not where an effect expects it to be. In such situations, according to the rule, the effect is unable to move the card.  This rule was officially codified in [[Dark Ages]], though [[Donald X]] had invoked it in card rulings previously.
  
:''See also: [[Stop-Moving rule]]''
+
It is possible for a card to lose track of itself, if it has an effect that tries to move itself, which is then thwarted by another effect moving it first.  For example, {{Card|Hermit}} loses track of itself when you don't buy anything in a turn, and try to trash it and gain a {{Card|Madman}}, but use {{Card|Scheme}} to top-deck Hermit before you trash it.  Because Hermit is not in play, where it expects itself to be, it loses track of itself, and does not trash itself.
 
+
The '''Lose Track rule''' was a superseded rule covering what to do with a card when it is not where an effect expects it to be.  In such situations, according to the rule, the effect is unable to move the card.  This rule was officially codified in [[Dark Ages]], though [[Donald X]] had invoked it in card rulings previously. It was replaced by the [[Stop-Moving rule]].
+
 
+
It is possible for a card to lose track of itself, if it has an effect that tries to move itself, which is then thwarted by another effect moving it first.  For example, {{Card|Hermit}} loses track of itself when you don't buy anything in a turn, and try to trash it and gain a {{Card|Madman}}, but use {{Card|Scheme}} to top-deck Hermit before you trash it.  Because Hermit is not in the discard pile, where it expects itself to be, it loses track of itself, and does not trash itself.
+
 
+
This rule only pertains to card ''movement''. Other effects related to the lost card still happen, as long as they are not contingent on the movement that was prevented.  For example, while Scheme prevents Hermit from moving to the trash, a Madman is still gained, since the gaining of a Madman did not depend on Hermit moving into the trash.  However, a Scheme that top-decks a [[Traveller]] ''will'' prevent an exchange from happening, since gaining the next card in the Traveller line is contingent on the previous Traveller returning to its pile.
+
  
 
== Official Rules ==
 
== Official Rules ==
 
* In rare circumstances an effect may try to move a card that is not where that effect expects the card to be. In those cases the card does not move - the effect has "lost track" of the card.  
 
* In rare circumstances an effect may try to move a card that is not where that effect expects the card to be. In those cases the card does not move - the effect has "lost track" of the card.  
 
* Losing track of a card prevents it from being moved, but does not stop anything else from happening.  
 
* Losing track of a card prevents it from being moved, but does not stop anything else from happening.  
** For example, if you {{Card|Procession}} a {{Card|Madman}}, Procession first puts Madman [[in play]]; then you resolve Madman, getting +2 Actions and drawing cards and returning Madman to the Madman pile; then Procession fails to put Madman into play again, because Procession expects to find Madman in play, but it is not there, it's in the Madman pile; then you resolve Madman again, only getting +2 Actions this time, since it says "if you do" before the card-drawing, and you did not actually return it to the Madman pile this time; then Procession fails to trash Madman since Procession again expects to find Madman in play and it is not there; and then you gain an Action costing {{Cost|1}} if you can.  
+
* For example, if you {{Card|Procession}} a {{Card|Madman}}, Procession first puts Madman in play; then you resolve Madman, getting +2 Actions and drawing cards and returning Madman to the Madman pile; then Procession fails to put Madman into play again, because Procession expects to find Madman in play, but it is not there, it's in the Madman pile; then you resolve Madman again, only getting +2 Actions this time, since it says "if you do" before the card-drawing, and you did not actually return it to the Madman pile this time; then Procession fails to trash Madman since Procession again expects to find Madman in play and it is not there; and then you gain an Action costing {{Cost|1}} if you can.  
 
* Cards do not lose track of cards that they move, only cards that other cards move.  
 
* Cards do not lose track of cards that they move, only cards that other cards move.  
** For example when Procession puts Madman into play, that does not cause Procession to lose track of Madman; it is Madman moving itself that causes Procession to lose track of it.  
+
* For example when Procession puts Madman into play, that does not cause Procession to lose track of Madman; it is Madman moving itself that causes Procession to lose track of it.  
 
* Things lose track of a card if something moves it, if it is the top card of a deck and gets covered up, or if it is the top card of a discard pile and gets covered up.
 
* Things lose track of a card if something moves it, if it is the top card of a deck and gets covered up, or if it is the top card of a discard pile and gets covered up.
  
 
== List of cards that invoke the Lose Track rule ==
 
== List of cards that invoke the Lose Track rule ==
Cards in italics have been [[Removed cards|removed]].
 
 
=== Card movers ===
 
=== Card movers ===
 
These have effects that either can lose track of a card they're trying to move, or can cause the card they moved to be lost track of by some other effect.  A few of these fall into both categories.
 
These have effects that either can lose track of a card they're trying to move, or can cause the card they moved to be lost track of by some other effect.  A few of these fall into both categories.
* {{Card|Vassal}}
+
* {{Card|Thief}}
* ''{{Card|Thief}}''
+
* {{Card|Replace}}
+
 
* {{Card|Possession}}
 
* {{Card|Possession}}
 
* {{Card|Watchtower}}
 
* {{Card|Watchtower}}
* ''{{Card|Royal Seal}}''
+
* {{Card|Royal Seal}}
 
* {{Card|Scheme}}
 
* {{Card|Scheme}}
 
* {{Card|Noble Brigand}}
 
* {{Card|Noble Brigand}}
Line 37: Line 28:
 
* {{Card|Warrior}}
 
* {{Card|Warrior}}
 
* {{Event|Travelling Fair}}
 
* {{Event|Travelling Fair}}
* {{Card|Villa}}
+
* {{Card|Prince}}
* {{Card|Faithful Hound}}
+
* {{Card|Tracker}}
+
* {{Card|Changeling}}
+
* {{Card|Cursed Village}}
+
* {{Card|Prince|oi=2}} (pre-errata)
+
* {{Card|Prince}} (post-errata)
+
 
* {{Event|Summon}}
 
* {{Event|Summon}}
  
In addition, all [[Reserve]] cards and [[One-shot]]s can be lost track of by any effect that tries to move them out of the play area, and all [[Duration]]s can be lost track of by any effect that expects them to be discarded during Clean-up.  [[Traveller]]s can be lost track of if exchanged, and can lose track of themselves if moved before they can be exchanged.
+
In addition, all [[Reserve]] cards and [[One-shot]]s can be lost track of by any effect that tries to move them out of the play area, and all [[Duration]]s can be lost track of by any effect that expects them to be discarded during Clean-up.
  
Notice: effects that reveal or set aside cards, then move them somewhere else, are not included here. It used to be that there were no triggers where "revealing" a card did something. That has now changed with Renaissance expansion pack (with {{Card|Patron}}). So there are possibly more cards that are now susceptible to losing track of another card because they reveal.
+
A couple cards on this list do not yet have interactions with current cards that can invoke the Lose Track rule, but their effects could theoretically lose track of cards. For example, Thief would lose track of any [[Treasure]] it trashed with an on-trash effect similar to {{Card|Fortress|Fortress's}}.
  
Effects that only trash cards, with no other movement of the card involved, are not included.  However, effects that try to set aside or trash a card ''after'' having first moved them into play or a discard pile ''are'' included.
+
For the most part, effects that reveal or set aside cards, then move them somewhere else, are not included here, as the act of revealing or setting aside a card does not (as of yet) trigger any sort of effect.  Likewise, effects that only trash cards, with no other movement of the card involved, are not included.  However, effects that try to set aside or trash a card ''after'' having first moved them into play or a discard pile ''are'' included.
  
 
=== Cards with covering-up effects ===
 
=== Cards with covering-up effects ===
Line 58: Line 43:
 
* {{Card|Border Village}}
 
* {{Card|Border Village}}
 
* {{Card|Death Cart}}
 
* {{Card|Death Cart}}
* {{Card|Crumbling Castle}}
 
* {{Card|Haunted Castle}}
 
* {{Card|Sprawling Castle}}
 
* {{Card|Fortune}}
 
* {{Card|Cemetery}}
 
* {{Card|Skulk}}
 
* {{Card|Cursed Village}}
 
  
 
{{Navbox Strategy}}
 
{{Navbox Strategy}}
[[Category:Rules]]
 

Please note that all contributions to DominionStrategy Wiki are considered to be released under the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial Share Alike (see DominionStrategy Wiki:Copyrights for details). If you do not want your writing to be edited mercilessly and redistributed at will, then do not submit it here.
You are also promising us that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource. Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

Cancel | Editing help (opens in new window)
Personal tools
Namespaces

Variants
Views
Actions
Navigation
Toolbox