Outtakes: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Werothegreat (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
Added some detail to several entries |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
* '''Dungeon''': Trash a card from your hand; discard a card; +3 cards | * '''Dungeon''': Trash a card from your hand; discard a card; +3 cards | ||
** Was originally in the [[Dominion (Base Set)|Base Set]]. It was moved to [[Intrigue]], then [[Dark Ages]], where it was finally cut for being too similar to existing cards. | |||
* '''Tower''': a [[Reaction]] that allowed you to gain a card costing up to {{Cost|5}} when another player bought a card costing {{Cost|6}} or more | * '''Tower''': a [[Reaction]] that allowed you to gain a card costing up to {{Cost|5}} when another player bought a card costing {{Cost|6}} or more | ||
* '''Campaign''': a [[one-shot]] that played all [[Attack]] cards in your deck | * '''Campaign''': a [[one-shot]] that played all [[Attack]] cards in your deck | ||
| Line 28: | Line 29: | ||
* '''Tithe Collector''': a [[handsize attack]] that only affected opponents with duplicate cards in hand | * '''Tithe Collector''': a [[handsize attack]] that only affected opponents with duplicate cards in hand | ||
* '''Barn''': +2 actions; +1 card per differently named card in play; then discard that many cards | * '''Barn''': +2 actions; +1 card per differently named card in play; then discard that many cards | ||
** A Cornucopia card that was cut due to space constraints. | |||
* '''War Axe''': an on-gain trashing attack | * '''War Axe''': an on-gain trashing attack | ||
* '''Raider''': a [[handsize attack]] that, like {{Card|Noble Brigand}}, attacks on gain as well as on play | * '''Raider''': a [[handsize attack]] that, like {{Card|Noble Brigand}}, attacks on gain as well as on play | ||
* '''Hatter''': +1 card, +1 action, play the top card of the [[Ruins]] pile | * '''Hatter''': +1 card, +1 action, play the top card of the [[Ruins]] pile | ||
* '''Rebuild''': [[remodel]] one of the top three cards of your deck, discard the other two, putting the gained card on top of your deck | * '''Rebuild''': [[remodel]] one of the top three cards of your deck, discard the other two, putting the gained card on top of your deck | ||
** Had lots of playtesting and was balanced, but was a dud with several playtesters. | |||
* '''Barbarian''': a trashing attack that replaces an opponent's card with a cheaper card of the same [[type]] | * '''Barbarian''': a trashing attack that replaces an opponent's card with a cheaper card of the same [[type]] | ||
* '''Mercenary''': a handsize attack that makes other players discard down to 2 cards and then draw one | * '''Mercenary''': a handsize attack that makes other players discard down to 2 cards and then draw one | ||
** The attack was too brutal. Margrave (as published) takes this in the other direction. | |||
* '''Cemetery''': a card that trashes other players' Victory cards at the end of the game | * '''Cemetery''': a card that trashes other players' Victory cards at the end of the game | ||
** Trashing one card was too weak, but trashing two was too strong. | |||
* '''[[Confusion]]''': a [[dead]] card with no other effect | * '''[[Confusion]]''': a [[dead]] card with no other effect | ||
** This was too similar to Curse to be worth taking up 30 cards in the box. | |||
{{Navbox Cards}} | {{Navbox Cards}} | ||
[[Category:Unpublished cards]] | [[Category:Unpublished cards]] | ||
Revision as of 20:28, 12 December 2013
After the release of Guilds, Donald X. Vaccarino published a lengthy list of Dominion outtakes—cards that he playtested and decided not to publish for one reason or another. The full list can be found here, and includes many early versions of cards that were eventually revised and released; what follows is a list of some of the most distinctive and interesting outtakes that are not simply early versions of eventually-published cards, but have been discussed elsewhere or been influential on game rules or future card design. Some have the same names as cards that ended up getting published.
- Dungeon: Trash a card from your hand; discard a card; +3 cards
- Tower: a Reaction that allowed you to gain a card costing up to
when another player bought a card costing 
or more - Campaign: a one-shot that played all Attack cards in your deck
- Bandit: a Thief-like card that could steal any type of cards
- Bribe: a Reaction card that you could reveal when you trashed a card to gain a new copy of the trashed card
- Keep: a cantrip that could discard for +
like Vault or Secret Chamber - Inn: +2 cards, +1 action, discard a card
- This proved to be too strong to cost
but is strictly worse than Laboratory so can't cost .
- This proved to be too strong to cost
- Procession: a Duration variant of Throne Room: play an Action now, and again on your next turn
- This card was too weak, and it was difficult to make it interact with other Duration cards.
- Landfill: a scaling alt-VP card that depended on the number of cards in the Trash
- "It played poorly and no one liked it." —DXV
- Transmute: a remodeler that Expanded the top card of your deck
- Kitchen: Play an Action card. Trash it. Gain an Action card costing up to
or more. Play it. - Enchant: a card that increased numerical values on other cards by 2
- Silver Mine: Gain a Silver.
- Market Square: a cantrip that allowed you to buy a card immediately and put it in your hand
- This card was cut because of the confusing ramifications of allowing buying during the Action phase.
- Manor: a half-Harem with +Buy
- This is too weak to cost
but is strictly better than Estate.
- This is too weak to cost
- Flea Market: a card that reduced the cost of cards that nobody had yet gained a copy of
- This was cut in part because it gave too strong an advantage to the first player.
- Mob: a trashing attack that digs for an opponents' Victory card and replaces it with a cheaper Victory card plus an Estate
- Jester: a card that let you play another card, swapping its various vanilla bonuses for other vanilla bonuses
- Craftsman: +1 card, +1 action, discard any number of cards, gain a card costing up to
per card discarded, putting it into your hand - Tithe Collector: a handsize attack that only affected opponents with duplicate cards in hand
- Barn: +2 actions; +1 card per differently named card in play; then discard that many cards
- A Cornucopia card that was cut due to space constraints.
- War Axe: an on-gain trashing attack
- Raider: a handsize attack that, like Noble Brigand, attacks on gain as well as on play
- Hatter: +1 card, +1 action, play the top card of the Ruins pile
- Rebuild: remodel one of the top three cards of your deck, discard the other two, putting the gained card on top of your deck
- Had lots of playtesting and was balanced, but was a dud with several playtesters.
- Barbarian: a trashing attack that replaces an opponent's card with a cheaper card of the same type
- Mercenary: a handsize attack that makes other players discard down to 2 cards and then draw one
- The attack was too brutal. Margrave (as published) takes this in the other direction.
- Cemetery: a card that trashes other players' Victory cards at the end of the game
- Trashing one card was too weak, but trashing two was too strong.
- Confusion: a dead card with no other effect
- This was too similar to Curse to be worth taking up 30 cards in the box.
